Pages

For People Crazy About 2D Animation!

Acme Punched! is for people crazy about 2D animation. It may be enjoyed by beginners and others, but it is aimed at animators who know already something about the process of animation and the basics of character animation. In large part, it will attempt to provide a deep look into the problem solving that goes on in my head as I work out a scene, often in step-by-step posts that I will sometimes enter in "real time", without knowing in advance what the outcome will be. Mistakes and false starts will not only be included but emphasized, so that the creative process of animation will be portrayed realistically. And, while my own bias is for 2D drawn animation, many of the effects and principles discussed here can apply to CGI 3D animation as well. I hope the blog will prove useful and instructive for all.

-Jim Bradrick

Monday, July 1, 2013

No. 44, Jim on a Limb: One (Part 2)

First Animatic

Here is the animatic I created using mostly just the drawings posted in Part 1.  An attempt was made to suggest the timing of the entire segment.


I invited the Director (me) into my office to look at it with me on my computer.  He took one glance at the video, shook his head and started for the door.

"Well, what do you think?" I (the animator) called out.

He turned back to look at me.  "They both start moving at once," he said.  "How is anyone supposed to know what to look at?"  Then he was gone.

I was disappointed, but only in myself.  He was right.  I had ignored a basic rule of animation, one I keep having trouble with when considered in its broadest sense.

Anticipation as a prelude to a particular action for a character is something I know well, and tend to do pretty well.  Someone pitching a ball winds up first; the windup of a baseball pitcher is the most obvious and exagerrated anticipation that we find in real life.  Any forward movement benefits from a windup of some kind, even if it is just the slightest gesture in the opposite direction.

But let's not forget that one purpose of the anticipation is to bring the eyes of the audience to the right place in time to appreciate the main action.

When you have two characters on screen at once, this becomes doubly important, and so on.  You don't want a viewer studying the eyes of the secondary character when the main character is about to do something important.

So who is leading here, and who following?  It is the man leading; he wants to lower the fox down to a level where he will have more control.  As the woman is connected to the fox by its jaws, she must come down also.

Is an anticipation by the man all we need here?  No, I believe we need more.  We need to show the man thinking before we show him acting on his thoughts.



Next:  The Man Takes Charge


Saturday, June 22, 2013

No. 43, One Year of Acme Punched!


What if you could be Acme punched...literally?


Just a brief message to note that this blog has been running for over a year now; my first post was on May 13, 2012.  As of this writing I have had almost 5,400 page views, which I think is not bad for a blog of such specialized and arcane interest.  I have readers on all six inhabited continents and on most major island nations as well.

Some of the posts require a lot of preparation and work but I have been getting just enough encouragement to keep me going.  Doing the blog also helps me to keep focused on my personal film, The Crossing, which has grown to become so complex that I sometimes don't have any idea when it will be finished.

Anyway I will carry on.  Please keep coming back; I will try to get something new up at least twice a month, and often it will be more.  Your comments also are always encouraged.  (I have just changed some settings so that more people can comment now!)

Meantime, keep animating, and keep traditional animation alive!  The big distributors may think that they have killed traditional animation in feature films, but even if that were true, there remain many more intimate markets, and I believe that in drawn animation there exists a charm and allure that must not be allowed to fade away.

-Jim Bradrick

Monday, June 17, 2013

No. 42, Jim on a Limb: One (Part 1)

Jim on a Limb


This is the first of my posts in which I am attempting something difficult, a piece of animation not in the books, and where I am not completely sure of myself.  Plus, I am letting my readers see from the beginning most of my thoughts and all of my attempts to get it right. In the words of the Anglo-American expression, I am "out on a limb".  For me it will be an adventure, and I invite you to ride along with me.
 
Have I mentioned that animating pantomime is harder than animating dialog?  Oh, yes.

The uninitiated think that dialog makes animation more complicated, but in fact it affords the animator much in the way of guidelines and direction.  The actor's performance, if expert, sets up most of the timing, emphasis and emotion for the discerning animator.  The performance can inspire the animator to strong poses and expressions.With a scene that is entirely in pantomime, on the other hand, the animator is the only actor, and all timing and other nuances of the performance must come from within.

The scene I am involved with here concerns  three characters--the woman, the man and the fox--each of whom must be made to perform convincingly not just in isolation, but in relation to the other two.

And the section of that scene I am focused on now is the most difficult I have faced to date.

The fox, held in the hands of the man, has bitten the woman in the nose.  In shock and pain, she has pulled away, but the fox has held on, forcing the man to lift the fox up in order to ease the strain on the woman's nose.  She has stopped, and slowly she lowers her head as the man carefully lowers the fox.  The man then relaxes a little and straightens himself, his head rising up warily as he keeps his eyes on the fox.  The woman watches the man.  Then the man tilts his head for a better look at the fox.  The woman pulls herself into an attitude of supplication and, looking now at the fox,  attempts a forced smile.  They end the scene in stalemate.

Let's take a look at some rough key drawings made while working this out. 

Fig. 1.  This is the last frame of the action shot where she has just been bitten by the fox and has jerked away.
Fig 2.  This represents an extreme closeup that will last about 30 frames, or 1 1/4 seconds.
Fig. 3.  First frame as we cut back to the same framing as before.  The characters have settled into their poses (compare to fig. 1).
Fig. 4.  The man and woman, watching each other, carefully lower the fox back down.
Fig. 5.  They have come down as far as they will go.  Short hold.  The woman still watches the man, but he has moved his attention now to the fox.

Fig. 6.  The man drops his shoulders and straightens up,  He is now regarding the fox with alarm and confusion.  How could this little animal do such a thing?
Fig. 7.  He begins to lower his head again but stops, hesitant.
Fig. 8.  He lowers his head the rest of the way and peers at the fox; he is disappointed and bewildered.
Fig. 9.  Now the woman turns her attention from the man to the fox.  This is an anticipation.
Fig. 10.  Unsure what to do, she turns her head a little and gestures as if about to speak to a human.
Fig. 11.  Realizing that that is futile, she instead tries to smile at the fox (perhaps that will help!), and helplessly brings her fists together in supplication.

So there are the key drawings as I see them now.  As of this writing I have not worked out the exact timing.

Wish me luck!



Next: Timing and Spacing, and the First Animatic

Monday, June 10, 2013

No. 41, Drawing Problem 1: The Eccentric Breakdown Drawing (Part 3)

My Own Solution


Back in April I challenged my readers to create their own eccentric breakdown drawing  to go between two of my extremes.  [Here is the link.] I had one entry, and it was a good one.  Now I want to show you what my own breakdown looks like, as I have finally finished animating that part of the scene.

Here is the pencil test:

To begin with, I have to admit I changed one of the extremes--but it was only the head.  Testing an eary version of the pencils, I felt that the woman came too quickly out of her long hold and into action.  There is always the risk that it will not look good when all of a characters' parts begin moving at one time.  Also, I decided it would be good if she smiled before she moved, so that the smile will be noticed; remember that rule?  One thing at a time, if you want each thing to be noticed.  This little movement also ends with a moving hold of the head only.

So, she lowers her head and smiles, then goes into her pose, then ducks out of the way as the man brings the fox past her head.  Finally, she moves in to examine the fox closely.

If you were following the Drawing Challenge mentioned above, you may be interested to see  my version of drawing 65, the breakdown drawing:





Thursday, May 30, 2013

No. 40, Scanner Trouble, Part 2: My Solution

If you recall, I had complained here about the fact that my upgrade to Mac OS 10.8, known as Mountain Lion, had rendered my Mustek large format scanner useless: no drivers available!

My scanner was, in the words of another online complainant, no better than a doorstop--a dead weight.

My goal was to try to find a fix for this other than replacing the scanner itself.

First, of course, I tried software.  Nothing worked, including VueScan, where I actually talked to the owner, who said that scanner drivers are notoriously badly written.  Mustek's website said to go to Apple and get a driver from them, but there was nothing there.

Then I thought: what if I could get an old Mac that was still running on an earlier operating system, and dedicate it to the scanner?  And that is what I did.  The scanner is now paired with an iMac running Snow Leopard.  I did still have to download a driver for that, but it worked.

The Mountain Lion is tamed!


Now I am happily back in business!

A special thanks to David Nethery, who posted a comment just a few days ago suggesting both Vue Scan, which he didn't know I had tried, and the fact that Brother makes a couple of scanners that might have done the job for me, had I found it necessary to replace the Mustek.

Monday, May 20, 2013

No. 39, Problem Six: Fox Bites Nose (Part 5)

For the next couple of weeks I will be working on my website, bradrick.com, to update it, make it easier for me to change by using Wordpress.org, and increasing its search engine optimization.  Meanwhile, here is a pencil test that came out right the first time!


Take One


Here I had to make the woman react as the fox bit and held onto her nose.  This called for a violent "take" of some kind, as she is struck by the shock (and some pain!) of being bitten by the cute little fox.  Takes are not something I have been much called upon to do in my career, so I looked in Richard Williams' book The Animator's Survival Guide at some classic formulae for takes which he had learned from animators of the Disney and Warners studios.


 The anticipation is on two's, then the upward "take" has two inbetweens on one's, followed by a "settle" on two's.  I cut to blank frames at the end because I want to cut away to a closeup at that point, without first going into a hold, and this shows me that the poses read well.

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

No. 38, Problem Six: Fox Bites Nose (Part 4)

A Reminder:

As this blog is focused on detail and the small decisions that accumulate to make a larger picture, in these posts we will often examine short sections of a scene instead of the whole scene.  This helps keep the presentation concise and clear.  However, I want to remind you (and myself) that normally it is best to look at an entire shot or scene all at once, to judge its rhythm and pacing. I hope that in your own animation work, you will not lose sight of this important idea.

Bad, Not-So-Bad, Better, Best


This time we will look at a part of the action of the woman.  The man holds the fox in his hands, having just lowered it down from his head, and the woman has moved in close.  At the beginning she is looking at the man.  She then turns to the fox and reaches out her hand to tickle him under his chin.

I have four pencil tests to show you.  The first one I call...

The Bad



If there is one bad habit I am most often guilty of, it is that of making my rough drawings too detailed before testing the action even once.  When it works, it works, but when it doesn't, then I have unnecessarily wasted a lot of time and effort.  This is an example of that.  The poses looked good to me, I didn't see how it could go wrong, and so I spent a lot of time drawing detailed hands, for instance, because I thought the animation was a sure thing.

It wasn't.  The head and body work fine, but in this first test I could see that the arms and hands are not saying what I want to say.  The left hand passes too close to her nose on its way to reach out to the fox, and the right hand makes a fluttery gesture that only distracts viewer attention from the main action.

The Not-So-Bad



Right hand fixed.  Left hand has been changed so that there is much more drag; the wrist leads the hand.  At first I thought this might be too theatrical a gesture for this character, but she is about to admire the cute little fox, so she is in a playful mood.

But now, as often happens when you change one thing, something else becomes apparent that needs to change.  The action in this test begins and ends with holds.  Everything begins moving all at once, and everything also stops all at once at the end.   It goes against the good advice that, going into a hold, everything should not arrive all at once.  This is something that people will notice, or at least it is something that will ring false even if they don't know why.  Rather than appearing to be alive, the character looks robotic and mechanical. (I did think that  the tickling movement of the finger that will begin as soon as her left hand comes to rest might be the overlapping movement I needed, but now I see a need for more overlap.)

The Better


Now the unfurling of her left hand has been delayed and finishes after her body and right hand have come to rest.   You can still see the  ghost images of the hand where they have been erased from other drawings.

To fill out the delayed movement of the left hand, I tried a moving hold of her fist, but it isn't working right.

The Best


I changed the left arm so that it moves in close to the body in an anticipation of the main movement.  This works pretty well now and I am happy with the result.



Pencil testing sometimes goes like this, through four or more versions before the scene looks and feels just right.  Other times, the animator hits it right the first time through.  In this case, the main thing I did wrong was to draw in too much detail before the rough movement was proven in pencil test.

"LET THAT BE A LESSON TO YOU!" the director (I) shouted at the animator ( me.)

Let it be a lesson to you, too.